Provocation defence to be scrapped
.
Murderers will no longer be able to claim they were provoked into committing their crime under a law change the government is planning.
Cabinet will consider the proposal in the next two to three weeks but Prime Minister John Key has given his approval, making it almost certain to go ahead.
Justice Minister Simon Power, in a speech to the Institute of Policy Studies in Wellington today, unveiled a raft of areas the government was looking at including updating the law around sexual crimes, better protection for children and the partial defence of provocation.
The jury yesterday found him guilty of murder.
The defence has sparked heated debate after Otago University tutor Clayton Weatherston argued he was provoked into stabbing girlfriend Sophie Elliott stabbed 216 times and was only guilty of manslaughter.
He told reporters: “I think (the defence has) had its time, I think there are other mechanisms on the statute book that deal with some circumstances that may arise”.
Mr Power said the defence “wrongly enables defendants to besmirch the character of victims, and effectively rewards a lack of self-control”.
Once Cabinet gave approval a bill would be drafted.
“It would be fair to say there would be lot of support around the Cabinet table for the move that Simon Power is leading,” he said.
Mr Key indicated Cabinet would be advancing it.
His defence argued that Mr Brown came on strongly to Ambach and might have attempted to rape him, leading Ambach to lose control and beat him with a banjo before ramming the stem down his throat.
Ferdinand Ambach this month favourably used the defence in his trial for killing Auckland man Ronald Brown, 69.
“It was on its own time track, I have been very careful to make no comment on the Weatherston trial or for that matter any other trial.
Mr Power denied today’s announcement was knee-jerk reaction to recent cases saying the work had been going on for some time.”
He would have delayed the speech had a verdict not been delivered.”
He would have delayed the speech had a verdict not been delivered.
.