Fight brewing over NZ rugby changes
.
The New Zealand Rugby Union (NZRU) faces a public backlash of calamitous proportions if it goes ahead with announced changes to next year’s provincial competition format.
Momentum is gathering in the provinces among some unions, supporters and the rugby media for the NZRU to scrap those changes or face the consequences.
The Air New Zealand Cup (ANZC) is enjoying unprecedented popularity this season and is proving to be one of the most competitive and evenly fought since the old NPC was established in 1976. On a Sky Reunion programme poll conducted this week, more than 70 percent voted for the ANZC competition to remain unchanged.
Crowd numbers are generally well up, and television viewing audiences were up more than 86 percent after four rounds.
New teams Tasman, Counties Manukau, Hawke’s Bay and Manawatu have taken time to get up to speed onfield, but now, four years down the track, they are more than matching it with the big boys. The quality of rugby has been excellent, the All Blacks are keen to play whenever they get an opportunity and several exciting new players have been uclose tothed. On their day, any team can beat the other, as has been proven so far in 2009.
Tasman, Northland and Counties Manukau, who struggled financially in the initial stages of the ANZC, have now cut their cloth to fit and are keeping their heads above water. The Heartland competition kicked off in similar exciting fashion last week. Four will drop out of the current 14 team competition to form a first division, effectively a second division, which will also include two promoted Heartland teams, making a six-team division. . Also, if Tasman or Manawatu were demoted, most of their best now almost entirely home-grown players would leave for premier unions.
The problem is that the Heartland teams have little chance of being competitive.
Under a list of criteria to remain in the premier division, onfield performance is only a 20 percent factor and that, like the other criteria, is judged over the past four years.
Under a list of criteria to remain in the premier division, onfield performance is only a 20 percent factor and that, like the other criteria, is judged over the past four years. Promotion relegation of up to two teams is an option being considered.
The Heartland competition will comprise 10 teams.
.
The changes were adopted after a series of workshops involving New Zealand’s 26 provincial unions, Super 14 franchises and the New Zealand Rugby Players Association